The Decade of the Superhero Film

Each decade has a certain type of film that it’s remembered for. The eighties had family films like Back to the Future, Ghostbusters and the last two Star Wars films. The nineties had action films like Con Air, The Rock and Goldeneye mixed with Disney classics The Lion King and Toy Story. For the noughties it can only be superhero films.

Bryan Singer kicked the decade off with X-Men (***), a solid if not spectacular blockbuster which he would follow-up with a vastly improved classic of a sequel in 2003 (*****). The crime against humanity that is Brett Ratner took control of the third and well, the soon-to-be-typed score will say it all (*).

Superman returned in Superman Returns (**) with Singer again at the helm. It wasn’t the commercial or critical hit Warner Bros was looking for so a reboot of the franchise has been talked about ever since and will eventually hit our screens with Christopher Nolan taking up the role of advisor to whoever eventually directs.

Nolan provided one of the two biggest superhero franchises of the noughties. Batman Begins (****) was a successful reboot and a great superhero film despite feeling a little clichéd upon repeat viewings. Like Singer he followed it up with a far superior sequel in The Dark Knight (*****) which is undoubtedly the biggest summer blockbuster of the whole decade raking in over $1 billion. It was a comic book film for the masses, helped no-end by the Oscar-winning performance from the late Heath Ledger. The Joker of that film will sit alongside Hannibal Lecter, Darth Vader and Biff as one of the greatest film villains.

The other major franchise was Sam Raimi’s Spiderman films. The first (***) was everything it needed to be, helped no end by a great Willem Dafoe performance as Spidey’s nemesis Green Goblin. A performance that even managed to override the awful Goblin costume made for the film. The sequel, once again, was an amazing improvement (****) and was aided by another fantastic villain, this time Doctor Octopus as played by Alfred Molina. However the third was a cluster-fuck (*) and it was a great example of why studios should fund and not run their films. They wanted Venom, Raimi did not. The result was awful.

Towards the end of decade Marvel decided to take matters into their own hands and their film studio gave us its first offering. The Robert Downey Jr Show (feat. Ironman) (****) was a great comeback for the charming actor who every geek has a crush on and a great film to boot, doing very well in the summer of 2008 and resulting in a sequel earlier this year (***).

Of course I can’t mention superhero comics without looking at their alter-ego, graphic novels. Zack Snyder is the guy to look at first. His first was the highly-stylised 300 (**) and enjoyable action film with more homoerotic undertones than Top Gun. He followed that up by making the film adaptation of what many agree is the greatest graphic novel of all time.

Alan Moore’s Watchmen is a classic, a classic that I hold in very high esteem and read every year. For that very reason I haven’t seen the film though I understand that it’s an adaptation that’s almost too faithful despite the altered climax. Unfortunately for Snyder he was only ever in a lose-lose situation with that film, due to the nature of the geeks whose favourite comic he’d decided to adapt.

There have been plenty more I’ve missed and there will be plenty more to come. Marvel are kings of the comic book films right now after two successful Ironman flicks but other studios are fighting back. Christopher Nolan will bring us the third Batman flick very soon as well as working on the already-mentioned Superman reboot. Elsewhere Columbia Pictures are working on their Spiderman reboot while DC begins work on Green Lantern which gives us the tantalising prospect of Martin Campbell directing the always-awesome Ryan Reynolds.

The Avengers Assemble - The cast and director at Comic Con

At Comic Con this week they showed off Thor and Captain America for the first time as well as bringing together the cast and director of their superhero ensemble behemoth, The Avengers. It’s what geek dreams are made of. Robert Downey Jr and Samuel L Jackson will lead the charge, with Chris Evans’ Captain America, Chris Hemsworth’s Thor, Jeremy Renner (of Hurt Locker fame’s) Hawkeye, Scarlett Johansson’s Black Widow and Mark Ruffalo taking over from Edward Norton as The Hulk. All of them under the watchful eye of geek-favourite, director Joss Whedon.

Eventually every super hero will have had his day at least, maybe twice. At this stage reboots will become increasingly popular but that, despite what I said in my post about sequels, may not be a bad thing. The difference between rebooting films like Karate Kid or Nightmare on Elm Street and this is the wealth of possibilities each superhero has. There are so many characters, so many stories to take inspiration from that reboots might well be a good thing for these types of films. But as always, time will tell.

And here is the unplanned part 2 of my article!

64 Responses to The Decade of the Superhero Film

  1. So many hero movies, so little time!

  2. You forgot a few, most of them not very good – Daredevil (2003), League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2003), Hulk (2003), Catwoman (2004), Hellboy (2004), Elektra (2005), Fantastic Four (2005), Ghost Rider (2007), Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (2007), Hellboy 2: The Golden Army (2008), The Incredible Hulk (2008), and X-men Origins: Wolverine (2009).

    I personally am excited for X-Men Origins: Magneto, even though it’s not slated to release until 2012. However, the small disaster that was “Wolverine” makes me nervous.

    Also, when the hell is Wonder Woman going to get her day? Especially after the large disaster that was Catwoman.

  3. Great article. I agree with the ratings of most of your choices, too, although I enjoyed “Superman Returns” a great deal and would’ve rated it higher. The first X-Men movie really should have been called “Wolverine,” as his character dominated what should have been a team movie (and poor Patrick Stewart got the short-end of the stick in each of the movies…wasteful). Now, if they could only get a Wonder Woman movie done, and done right–hopefully without that awful new costume…

  4. Can’t wait to see Christopher Nolan’s reboot of Superhman…it should be great!

    http://www.wutevs.wordpress.com

  5. Am I the only one who doesn’t like superhero movies?

  6. and hopefully soon….Ninja Turtles! Would love to see a solid reboot with a darker tone.

    http://www.dawnoftheninja.com ? perhaps?

  7. Ugh, reboots. To me a reboot is the studio saying, “Yeah, we really bent you over good for the sake of a dollar in the last film(s). But in order for us to make more money we decided to start over and make a decent movie again.” My big problem with reboots is they muddle any sense of continuity. In comics it’s kind of understood that there is no continuity because popular characters wind up having multiple books each month dedicated to them and they’re all telling different stories. But in the movies, you have one character’s movie coming out every 2-4 years with no overlap. There’s no reason you can’t establish some sort of continuity.

    However, from a strictly silverscreen standpoint, the most successful film franchise of all time has arguably zero continuity. Until the latest two chapters, the James Bond franchise was primarily made up of 20-some stand alone movies featuring the same character in different stories. So maybe comic movies don’t need to “reboot” all the time (especially when it’s been less than 5-10 years since the last film), maybe they just need to focus on telling really great stories with some fantastic characters.

  8. I’ve been loving the current trend to Comic Book movies. Yeah, there have been a few big disappointments (I’m looking at you, Superman. Shame on you.). But movies like Sin City, 300, Batman Begins, Iron Man, Spiderman, and the like have introduced a whole new narrative style and have pushed the boundaries of film in new ways. The biggest draw for me toward comic book films is that they are already written. There are decades of stories and character development. To find a good story isn’t hard at all. Whenever one gets picked up by a major studio, I’m always holding my breath however. There’s a precarious edge that directors walk between staying true to the story and producing the “summer blockbuster that appeals to all ages and creates an entire line of marketable goods.” I always cheer for those that err on the side of story.

  9. I enjoyed Watchmen and the X-men films, but found so many of the comic book films of the last decade to be seriously lacking. Wonder Woman has and always will be my favorite comic book. I have heard rumors that there is a movie in the works. I only hope they don’t cast Megan Fox or some other vapid starlett to play her. And I’m not sure how an invisible jet is going to translate to the big screen.

  10. For someone who hates these kinds of movies (and I do) I sure have been sucked in to seeing almost every movie mentioned here (and in the comments!) Yikes. I guess my curious nature always gets the better of me…

  11. I love all of the superhero films. Well, not all, but it’s nice to see something from youth on the big screen.

  12. I can’t WAIT for Avengers! I love Joss. These movies have all been really fun, I’m glad they’re keeping it up!
    http://www.denwrites.com

  13. No Kick Ass? I thought that movie took the superhero genre and threw it on its head, throwing in some realism and actual violence while it was at it. The people I know either loved it or hated it, but I loved it.

  14. Definitely the Superhero decade.

    I’m glad they are rebooting Spiderman though. I liked the movies at first, but after replaying them a lot, they could have been much better.

  15. @jknitt, I agree!
    I am not feeling Mark Ruffalo as the Hulk. It just seems weird to me. Norton played it better than Eric Banna but I think if your going to change the Hulk again go for some unknown. The movie already has enough stars to fill the sky!

  16. I think you’re right on. It seems like a new superhero movie comes out every year. I agree with most of your reviews, too, but I think that the third X-Men movie wasn’t nearly as bad as people said (I hated Superman Returns more.)

  17. Oh I love the super hero theme. This decade gave us some spectacular entertainment.

  18. Twas a pretty good decade for comic heroes indeed! Thanks for the recap.

  19. Most of the Comic Movies have been good, people really forgot about Daredevil thogh. The eralier movies could be done over like The Hulk and I figure they would be better flicks.

    • There’s not enough room to list all the comic movies (good OR bad)! The Punisher, Catwoman, Elektra, Fantastic Four, and on and on and on… The most fun is when people don’t realize it’s a comic book movie like Men In Black or Road to Perdition.

  20. Comics have really come into their own in the last decade or so. It’s great that people are starting to realise the great story value they offer.

    Can’t wait for more…

  21. You make some interesting observations, but I think there’s one glaring omission here and that’s you don’t even mention the success of Wesley Snipes as Blade, the vampire hunter.

    Made for a relatively cheap $45 million, it grossed $70 million domestically and $131 million worldwide and spawned two sequels (one good and one bad) and a lousy TV series.

    But Blade as it’s Wikipedia entry shows had a greater impact than just it’s minor success:

    “Blade was one of the first successful comic book based films to be released after the disastrous performance of Batman & Robin. Its success convinced Marvel to develop the X-Men film series as well as the Spider-Man film series.”

    Though Snipes is a jailbird now due to his problems paying his taxes, it’s not too far off-base to suggest it was Blade that made all these following super hero flicks possible.

  22. Love your article and congrats for ‘sitting on the wordpress homepage’! Found you there!

    Best wishes

  23. Man, I am still bummed they didn’t keep Edward Norton for the Hulk but still, the Avengers is going to be a great movie. I’m curious now if they have a cast for the Justice League yet

    http://www.thecooldown.wordpress.com

  24. Reboots can be really fun, at least for me, especially with the updated technology. They can really take the character in different directions. I’m thinking of Batman in the early 90s and then now in the 2000s – it’s like they’re totally different, but they’re still Batman.

    With Love and Gratitude,

    The Intentional Sage

  25. I can’t wait for the Avengers movie! It should be sick, but I’ll look forward to Green Lantern for the moment

  26. I didn’t want to like Snyder’s Watchmen. I like Moore’s Watchmen and didn’t know if I could separate one from the other.

    After seeing it in IMAX…. I did.

    Two different properties each with their own flaws and wins. If you can divorce yourself from judging it by the book, it’s a fun little movie.

  27. what really got me though was not just the comic book movies, which were amazing to say the least, but the fact that graphic novels were screenplayed was awesome.

    As for the Green Lantern movie, at first I didn’t think Ryan Reynolds could do it but after recently watching Smokin’ Aces, I think he’ll easily pull it off. I’m stoked.

  28. Reading this got me to thinking about Comic-Cons around the country. Producers are running around them looking for the next new, undiscovered comic. NPR in fact did a piece about it some years back, Hollywood’s search for the next best movie. During the NPR piece they ran into some guys who wrote a screenplay, but failing to get interest in it they hired an artist to turn it into a comic. They then took it around to the Comic-con conventions hoping to catch the eye of a producer.

  29. I am so excited to see what Joss Whedon does with them.

    I hve to say, you may want to look into seeing ‘Watchmen’. I myself am an avid reader of the novel and I can tell you, it is possible (but rare) to love both. Dare I say it…I even preferred the film’s ending.

    It’s worth seeing it for Haley’s Rorschach if nothing else.

  30. Cool blog! Although, I’m one of the few who enjoyed Superman. I’m not saying it’s a great film, but I did enjoy it.

    Keep up the good work.

  31. When is Thor or the Avengers due out?

    I wonder if Thor will feature his early alter-ego the criplled doctor who found a cane which turns into Thor’s hammer?

  32. BATMAN 3, HOLY CRAP, I MIGHT BE ONE OF THOSE PPL GRABBING HIS SLEEPING BAG AND HANG OUT UNTIL OPENING NIGHT SO I CAN BE THE FIRST ONE, LOL

  33. Sure, there were a lot of awesome superhero movies that were made… but not every comicbook hero SHOULD have his day. Here’s my top 5 list of WORST comic book superhero movies ever made. http://bit.ly/dbTLZH

  34. Did we have to change wonder womans outfit though – As a kid, the wonder woman poster stayed up way longer than Farrah

  35. Great blog!

  36. I was never a big comic person but I sure do love comic book movies! I’ve seen many of those if not all of them. Yeah, I don’t know about the constant rebooting but if it turns out to be a fun movie to watch I’ll end up checking it out.

  37. Like this. Thanks for sharing these films

  38. The Watchmen was a great movie, seeing some of the scenes come to life from the comic book gave me chills.
    I’m very nervous about the Avengers though, it might be Joss Whedon’s downfall. I don’t know how you make a movie with that many major players. But if anyone can do it, it will be the man that made Buffy!

  39. Great entry!
    I always lament Spiderman 3…it should have been so good…they had about ten villains too many.
    I watched Watchmen (yeah I went there), went in with an open mind, I loved it personally…I agree with savannahmazda…Jackie Earl Haley is worth checking out if nothing else. I really thought the film complimented the book.

  40. Phillip Frangules

    Very interesting article. IMO the novelty of the comicbook movie has worn off, but I guess that’s to be expected if studios think they can make money off an idea…

  41. I really love the era we are living, I love comics and I love movies as well, hence the combo is great to me, but…. in the other hand, I’m a bit frustrated with the movies industry for the last 2 years, there hasn’t been a lot of good movies lately…

  42. My father is superhero, I like superman ha ha.

  43. Great post. I’ve been in love with superheroes since I was old enough to read. It must be hard to try to encapsulate everything about a superhero, who may have a fifty year pedigree, in a two hour movie. I’d like to see more broadcast networks take on a darker, grittier version of some of my favorite heroes and put them on in the late evening and really explore the characters over a long period of time.

  44. awesome article. You’ve summed it up quite well. It was the decade of Superhero Movies, but I don’t think it will end there. I think there will be plenty more to come. This was just the beginning in my opinion.

    one question though, did you really think that lowly of 300? was that opinion based off the fact that you read the graphic novel first?

  45. Hey! Great post & Thanks for sharing it. The SuperHero Films have been very entertaining.

    your friends, XR VOLUME

  46. Great post, i’m loving these superhero movies too. But like your other post, there are the stinkers out there. Thanks for sharing.

  47. I cannot wait for the Avengers film! All these teasers just make it all the harder, I really hope it lives up to the hype!

  48. Love the Superhero,But I did not read the comic,just movies of Superhero.

  49. any suprehero movie always exciting.
    i never miss it.

    nice read man..
    thanks

  50. Dame can’t wait for all this bad ass movies to come out

  51. I have always loved superhero movies. My aunt used to take us all the time when we were kids and I have loved them ever since. My favorite hands-down of the last few years was Watchmen, one of the only movies that I have paid to see in the theatre multiple times. I’m also looking forward to more X-Men origins movies. Cant wait!

  52. Biff was a great villain, wasn’t he? Good one!

  53. I have loved them ever since. My favorite hands-down of the last few years was Watchmen, one of the only movies that I have paid to see in the theatre multiple times. I’m also looking forward to more X-Men origins movies. Cant wait!

  54. haha i never thought about it until i saw your article. it truly IS the decade of superhero films. but i have to say Christopher Nolan’s revamp of Batman is the best of the decade.

  55. Waiting for Green Lantern ! June 2011~!

  56. Awesome article! I’m a huge Batman fan, so it was nice to see him get some well-deserved attention.
    I was a little bummed with no love for Hellboy, but you did an impressive job of chronicling the era of the superhero movie!

  57. Carlos Angel Correz

    About “re-boots”, I have often been curious what it would be like if several film makers all made the same movie with their own unique interpretation.
    So I don’t really mind re-boots as long as they bring some fresh new view to a familiar story.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s